Learn more about BikingToronto and Singer Kwinter
NEVER MISS AN UPDATE: Click here to join over 900 other people and get updates and free stuff!

The Toronto Star’s public editor says “Cyclists Should Be Shot” article is a joke, and free speech

The Toronto Star’s public editor, Kathy English, has published a retort to people upset that their “opinion columnist” Rosie DiManno wrote that cyclists are sanctimonious and “should be shot”, saying that people are over-reacting to a joke and that DiManno has a right to write down those opinions, and that the Star has a right to publish them.

So… what do you think?  To me this sounds like the Star (and especially English) was not doing their job.  Sure, DiManno is a horrible columnist and plays to the segment of Star readership who probably also read the Toronto Sun, but shouldn’t the Star aim higher than the crap in the Sun?

If this column advocated violence against a visible minority, or gay people, or followers of a certain religion, would it have been published.  No.

A column that contained the phrase “Muslims should be shot”, or “Asian people should be shot” or “same sex couples should be shot” would not have seen the light of day, and if it had both English and DiManno would be out of a job.

Quote below.  If you get the Star’s paywall pop-up, just re-load the page and hit the stop button after the article loads and before the pop-up appears.  It appears the Star pays as much attention to their paywall technology as it does their opinion columnists’ hate speech.

The newsroom simply did not expect most readers would believe DiManno was actually inciting violence or hatred by referring to cyclists as the top of her personal list of “People Who Should Be Shot” or using clever word play to label cyclists “ped-aphiles.”

“We don’t share the concern that readers who dislike cyclists will believe as a result of reading this column that shooting or otherwise deliberately harming cyclists is OK and act on this belief, or that cyclists are comparable to criminals who molest children,” Davenport said.

“Our view is that the ironic tone and context of the column as a whole and of this line in particular are enough to make clear that this reference is not meant in any way to be read literally.”

That makes sense to me. The phrase that any individual or group “should be shot” is a common figure of speech, not an incitement to violence. The Cambridge Dictionaries Online defines it as being used “when you think that someone’s actions are extremely unreasonable.”

Full article: Columnists free to express outrageous opinions: Public Editor | Toronto Star.

Recent Posts

bloor-infographic1

TRUTH: The business of bikes and parking

Click on through to Spacing to see the full infographic. There has been some debate about whether bike lanes on Bloor would hurt or harm businesses. Spacing is republishing this infographic from our Fall 2014 issue to help inform the discussion. View Full Graphic: INFOGRAPHIC: The business of bikes and parking – Spacing Toronto

bikechain

VIDEO: A DIY repair shop created by students for students

A great video introduction to U of T’s BikeChain from Global News (except there’s an ad that runs before it): ‘Bikechain’ was created in 2005 as a student project serving the University of Toronto student community. This DIY bicycle repair shop is based out of the St. George campus and is open to everyone on […]

pollution-map1

MAPS! Helping cyclists avoid smoggy routes in Toronto and Montreal

  Amazing tool!  Played with it a long time.  Very telling that when you turn off the street map, high pollution levels still indicate where roads (and especially highways and the airport) are, and where the ravines (without highways) are. It is essentially a Google Map with an extra layer representing the average concentration of […]

blue shirt

OH YEAH! Get Biking Toronto Updates, Win A Shirt

This is on until midnight on Saturday, April 30th, 2016! If you’re a regular visitor to Biking Toronto, you may notice little asks for you to join the update list.  This list updates you about new things on the site (and then you decide what you want to click through and read).  There are over […]

10697830754_444ae89432_z

NEWS: Bloor Bike Lanes Pilot Should Be a Council No-Brainer. Here’s Why It’s Not. 

An excellent piece in Torontoist about why a bike lane pilot designed to collect data about benefits/detriments and overwhelming supported by the community is getting static from politicians: There really should have been little to no debate about this 2.5 kilometre bike lane pilot project running along Bloor Street West from Shaw Street to Avenue […]