Learn more about BikingToronto and Singer Kwinter

How to Save the Cycling Committee

This is a guest post by Anthony Humphreys, a father of two daughters who lives in South Etobicoke and is a Toronto cycling advocate. Anthony attended the City of Toronto Executive Committee meeting on Wed, April 20th concerning the elimination of 21 citizen advisory committees.

From my perspective, yesterday’s Executive Committee meeting went “Not well”.

Over forty people signed up to make deputations, but because they dealt with us very last (starting at or near 6:00pm), only about 33 people or so remained to the end to speak for their five minutes.

Full House at April 20, 2011 Executive Committee, photo by Yvonne Bambrick

Full House at April 20, 2011 Executive Committee, photo by Yvonne Bambrick

Of those, two or three people spoke about the aboriginal committee, tenants committee, and bring back the don committee; there was also one each to defend the French Language and the Solid Waste committee. The rest were there to speak about the cycling and/or pedestrian committees; which was at least half of the speakers. More people spoke about the cycling committee specifically than any other committee. (I am so proud of our cycling community!)

In the end, the Executive Committee really seemed like they did not want to hear us (Did putting us off to the end not give it away?). With a few exceptions, the majority of the interactions were with Councillors who are not on the committee (like Shelly Carol, Adam Vaughan, Mike Layton, & Pam McConnell) and in the end the committee voted in favour of the recommendations.

We lost here, but we still have two weeks to make a difference…

Because I’ve been a regular attendee (but never on the committee formally) I can attest to why the committees are unpopular with citizens, staff and councillors. On the other hand, I’m not such an Idealist that I’ll heavily defend the committee like this.

In my own deputation I agreed that the committee structure was far too formal, intimidating, and required citizens to learn the procedures and terminology.In addition, there is still limited interaction (ie deputations) for the public with the committees. However, I want to recognize that this rigid formality is also the strength of the committee. If a presentation is made by a citizen or group and report is presented to the committee then staff are obliged to respond in kind, that is with their own report. This is why I why I went to defend the committee.

However, I did offer a middle ground; I did offer a compromise solution. I suggested that the committee be scaled back to meet only a few times per year, say four — or even twice — a year (rather than the 10 or 11 times they traditionally met). And I suggested that the council keep this for a couple of years, or perhaps this term of council. This would give everyone (council, staff and citizens) time to assess the true value of the committees against the other means of engagement that staff are planning in lieu of having the committees. Staff would engage using social media, town halls, etc, and the committees would still exist, but at a much scaled back level.

I know from experience that many of the public consultation meetings don’t work; they become shouting matches between those who want keep the status quo against those who want the proposed changes. At these meetings, no compromise is possible, and no one is forced to look for a solution. Town halls can offer some good ideas, but there’s no obligation to follow-through. On-line Social-media is limited, and can lack many of the subtleties of face to face interaction. Committees, on the other hand, are forced to work for solutions, they need to find reasonable compromises. And these committees also act as a type of watch-dog on over our City Council, at least within the scope of their mandate.

But they do have a cost in staff time in direct proportion to their frequency of meetings. Which is why I offered the compromise that I did. Keep the cycling committee, but have it meet much less frequently. Give all of us (Council members, staff, as well as citizens) a period of time to wean off the committees, especially if the intention is to kill them eventually. Let this become more of an evolutionary change than and abrupt change so we can all be sure that we are not throwing out the baby with bath water, give us all confidence that we are not losing too much when the time comes to kill the committee entirely. Provide us with time and a means to transition to new ways of doing things. This is what I am asking for, and I hope you will ask your councillors for something like this as well.

BikingToronto guest posts are intended to open our readership up to other voices and news about cycling in Toronto. Interested in writing a guest post for BikingToronto? Just contact us with your idea for a post (or series of posts) and we can talk about it. Please remember that BikingToronto is a responsible and positive outlook on all things related to cycling in Toronto, and has a code of conduct.





RECENTLY ON BIKING TORONTO:

Sangyal-helps-rebuild-bikes-at-Bike-Pirates-c-Siva-Vijenthira-600x800

EVENT: Sat, July 4 – Bike Pirates celebrates their 9th Birthday

Please join us this Saturday, JULY 4TH, for some fun, food, and high fives. We couldn’t have made it to 9 years without the support of this community!We will be outside the shop for part of the afternoon saying hello to our new Parkdale neighbours, so come by to see the shop in action, have […]

11355710_693219640806386_1704726468_n

INSTAGRAM: More Bells on Danforth

Bells on #Danforth! Looking east from Pape. #Danforthlovesbikes Danforth Loves Bikes! Follow BikingToronto on instagram! @bikingtoronto

bike-share-toronto.jpg.size_.xxlarge.letterbox

NEWS: Nearby bikeshare station may raise your home’s value

Having a bike share station outside your front door might do more than give you a convenient way to ride to work — it might also boost the value of your home. According to a new study from McGill University, residential units in Montreal are worth more if they’re close to a Bixi station, Montreal’s […]

fatal-accident-closed-dufferin-st-in-vaughan-150629victor-biro1.jpg.size_.xxlarge.letterbox

NEWS: Cyclist dead following 2-vehicle collision on Dufferin St.

The cyclist wasn’t on the road (standing on sidewalk), but car struck a hydro pole, which then killed them. Awful. A cyclist has been confirmed dead by York Regional Police following a vehicle collision on Dufferin St. north of Steeles Ave. on Monday evening. Two cyclists were on the sidewalk corner of Dufferin St. and […]

IMG_20150629_180949510_HDR

OH YEAH! The Viaduct bikelanes get MORE green paint!

Well, I don’t know what’s going on.  This is a level of paying attention to cycling infrastructure on the Bloor Viaduct that, quite frankly, I thought I’d never see (and it pissed me off, often). But now, after the green paint that was laid down late last week in the bikelane, there is now MORE […]

please2015-06-28-18.16.41

FACEPALM: City closes Hoskin bikelane for PanAm Games

What’s a great idea?  Closing down one of the busiest bikelanes in the city and not providing a detour that’s safe for cyclists (and pedestrians) because of the “short distance of the inconvenience”. A sign erected on June 25 indicates the closure of the Hoskin bike lane for two months during the Pan Am Games. […]

11378773_1438257236482258_1995756473_n

INSTAGRAM: Bells on Danforth

Dipping into the instagram archives for this great pic from Bells on Danforth. Biking the viaduct and #thedanny with hundreds of people! #Danforthlovesbikes #biketoFollow BikingToronto on instagram! @bikingtoronto

2014CityBike-INTRO-KatieAaron-Opus-Photo-David-Niddrie-1632-testcrop2

OH YEAH: Easy Bikes – A New Name for Upright Bikes?

Interesting article from Momentum Mag from earlier this month: Did the Wall Street Journal just rename the most accessible, useful, and comfortable of all bicycle styles? Upright bicycles, sometimes referred to by Momentum Mag as city bikes, are hands down the best style of bicycle for daily use. A relaxed frame geometry and swept-back handlebars combine to […]

19135652672_f5254c9d6f_b

PHOTO OF THE DAY: Aquila

Source: Original photo – by uncomman on Flickr. I feel like this woman is a hardened cyclist in Toronto despite her delicate look. Helmet, water, bike lock and music ready to go. Compact commuter pack with carabiner all set. Swagger on two wheels, check plus. via Flickr. See this and 7,000+ other amazing bike photos […]

qq

INFRASTRUCTURE: Waterfront Toronto wants your feedback on the new Queen’s Quay

  Waterfront Toronto is asking for feedback about the new Queen’s Quay… but they’ve buried the feedback link down at the bottom of that link.  I’ve pulled out the relevant section for you below, but check out their page for more information. How to submit your feedback on Queen’s Quay Fill out this online form […]

Recommended Lights

"Frog" Lights

Planet Bike Light Combo

Planet Bike 5 LED Tail Light
Recommended Books
See More Books



RECENT NEWS POSTS: